Finding the best mattress can be tough, which is where our Brooklyn Bedding vs Purple comparison may be able to help.
Brooklyn Bedding and Purple are both well-known and trusted mattress manufacturers, offering a ton of benefits for a great night’s sleep. The question is, which one is better?
Today we’ll be comparing the two companies, focusing on their hybrid models. We’ll be looking at how they feel to sleep on, the materials they use and how they are constructed, and who they’re best for. We’ll also look at how they compare in terms of warranties, sleep trials, and prices.
Let’s take a look at what sets them apart first!
Main Differences Between Brooklyn Bedding vs Purple
The main differences between Brooklyn Bedding vs Purple are:
- Brooklyn’s Signature mattress can be customized with three firmness levels, whereas the Purple Hybrid only comes in a medium-firm level
- Brooklyn Bedding offers a 120-night sleep trial for their mattresses, whereas Purple offers a 100-night sleep trial
- Brooklyn Bedding requires you to test their mattresses for at least 30 nights before returning, whereas Purple only requires you to try it for 21 nights before returning
- Brooklyn’s Signature mattress is quite good for hot sleepers, whereas Purple’s Hybrid mattress is excellent for hot sleepers thanks to the Grid layer and the materials used
- Brooklyn’s Signature mattress is better for those on a budget, whereas the Purple Hybrid is more expensive
Brooklyn Bedding and Purple: The Mattresses Compared
So, what are Brooklyn and Purple mattresses like? We’ll be looking closely at their hybrid mattresses today, looking at their construction, materials, and feel. Let’s start with Brooklyn Bedding.
Materials and Feel
Brooklyn Bedding manufactures several different mattresses, including the Aurora Hybrid (with advanced cooling technology), the Sedona Hybrid (the most luxurious mattress they offer), the Bloom Hybrid (with natural materials including organic cotton), and the Bowery (which comes in hybrid or all-foam).
Today, we’ll be focusing on the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid, their best-selling model. You can choose between soft, medium, or firm.
Hybrid mattresses in general can be a good choice for hot sleepers, as the coils promote airflow to keep the mattress cool – it’s harder to achieve that airflow with all-foam mattresses. The Signature Hybrid is a cooling mattress, thanks to the coils, and the gel-infused quilted cover, which has been designed to provide a cooling effect whilst keeping you comfortable.
Being able to choose a firmness level is great because it enables you to pick the right one for your sleeping position. The soft and medium firmness levels contour to the body, thanks to the foam layers on top.
Those under 130lbs will find this to provide enough support. Side sleepers can also benefit from the soft and medium firmness levels, because it provides cushioning around the shoulders and hips, whilst conforming to the body, which helps to keep the spine in alignment.
Back and stomach sleepers may want to go for the medium or firm levels. This provides the right amount of support, without as much cushioning. This is especially helpful for stomach sleepers, who may find that they sink too far into a softer mattress, which can cause pain and discomfort.
While the top layer of foam contours to your body a little, it’s also very responsive, meaning it bounces back quickly. This is thanks to the TitanFlex foam, which is designed to have the pressure point relief and responsiveness of latex.
It has good motion isolation, which makes it a great choice for couples, as you won’t be disturbing each other at night. Good for light sleepers or those who toss and turn at night!
There are 5 layers to the Brooklyn Signature mattress:
- Cover – quilted memory foam with cooling gel
- Transition layer 1 – 1.5” of Energex foam
- Transition layer 2 – 2” of high-density memory foam (in the firm version)
- Support layer – 961 individually encased coils
- Base layer – 1.5” of dense support foam
The secondary layers are variable depending on the type you choose – if you go for the soft version, you won’t have the second layer of high-density memory foam.
There is a slight off-gassing smell with this mattress, but it’s not as bad as the off-gassing you get with all-foam mattresses, and it dissipates quickly.
Materials and Feel
Purple offers three mattresses, including the original Purple Mattress (an all-foam mattress) and the Purple Hybrid Premier (the most luxurious option from Purple). Today we’ll be looking at the Purple Hybrid, to compare it closely to the Brooklyn Signature.
The Hybrid mattress is another good option for hot sleepers. It sleeps incredibly cool. This is thanks to the grid system that Purple has created. The grid layer is made from a temperature-neutral elastic gel, and it flexes under pressure points whilst providing support.
The grid creates channels of air, which is great for improved air circulation. The interior coils at the bottom improve air circulation, while the cover is made from breathable material with side panels – again, to encourage airflow. If you normally find that mattresses are too hot for you, Purple is a great brand to check out.
In terms of sleeping positions, it’s a little more limited than the Brooklyn Signature, as you can’t choose your preferred firmness level.
The Purple Hybrid is available in medium firmness, but it works well for all sleeping positions and all weights. It has body contouring, but is still pretty responsive, meaning you won’t sink into it completely. The only downside is that if you love the feeling of being deeply cradled by your mattress, this will be too firm for you.
Couples will appreciate the great motion isolation this mattress provides, so you shouldn’t disturb each other if you move around a lot at night.
Let’s take a look at the layers in the Purple Hybrid:
- Cover – Stretchmax soft knit cover
- Grid Layer – 2” Purple Grid hyper-elastic gel
- Transition Layer – 1” high-density polyfoam
- Support Layer – 7.5” individually wrapped stainless steel coils
Like the Brooklyn Signature, there is a tiny amount of off-gassing with this mattress, thanks to the foam layer. It dissipates quickly.
Brooklyn Bedding vs Purple – Warranties and Test Times
Both Brooklyn Bedding and Purple offer 10-year warranties for their mattresses. They also offer sleep trials. Brooklyn has a 120-night sleep trial, while Purple has a 100-night sleep trial.
|Brooklyn||120 nights||10 years|
|Purple||100 nights||10 years|
It’s worth noting that Brooklyn requires you to try their mattresses for 30 nights before you return them, while Purple suggests a minimum of 21 nights. This is because it can take the body a little time to adjust to a new mattress, so you may have a few aches and pains for the first few nights.
Brooklyn Bedding vs Purple – Prices
There is a bit of a price difference between the two. Let’s take a look at how they compare and whether the price difference is justified:
The Brooklyn Signature is cheaper than the Purple Hybrid. For the queen size, you’ll be paying around $700 more for the Purple.
Is it worth it? Well, it depends on what you’re looking for. The good thing about Purple mattresses is that they sleep very cool. Given that many mattresses sleep warm, this is a great thing if you’re a hot sleeper.
It also has the advantage of the Purple Grid layer, which helps to relieve pressure points. The Grid layer is made from long-lasting materials, and the whole mattress is very durable. You might decide that the durability and excellent reputation of Purple make it worth investing extra money into.
However, we think the Brooklyn Signature is also great. Plus, you have the advantage of choosing the firmness level. Ultimately it will come down to a personal choice between the two, but it’s good to know upfront that there is a bit of a price gap there.
If you’re on a really tight budget, you might find some mattresses that suit you in our guide to the Best Mattresses Under $500.
Brooklyn Bedding vs Purple – Who Are These Mattresses Made For?
Who could benefit from a Brooklyn or Purple mattress? Let’s take a look at their main benefits again:
The Brooklyn Signature works well for hot sleepers, although it doesn’t sleep as cool as the Purple Hybrid. It has great airflow, while the gel-infused top layer also helps to keep you cool.
It works well for most sleeping positions. Because you can choose your firmness, you can customize your mattress to a certain extent. Side sleepers under 130lbs may enjoy the soft level, while sleepers over 130lbs (or back and stomach sleepers) may enjoy the support that the Medium and Firm levels provide.
It’s a great choice for couples, thanks to the excellent motion isolation.
Recap: You Should Love the Brooklyn Signature Mattress If You …
- Are a hot sleeper
- Want to choose how firm your mattress is
- Are part of a couple
- Have a slightly tighter budget to work with
Hot sleepers rejoice – the Purple Hybrid is excellent for keeping you cool. If you struggle to find a mattress cool enough for you, this is the one to go for. Each layer is designed to improve airflow, so you won’t have to worry about overheating at night.
It works well for all weights and sleeping positions. The only people that may want to steer clear are those that enjoy being cradled in their mattress – if you love to sink into a foam mattress, you might want to look elsewhere. Still, it’s a versatile mattress that should work well for most people. If you sleep in different positions, it’s a good choice.
It’s also great for couples – like the Brooklyn Signature, the Purple Hybrid has great motion isolation.
Recap: You Should Love the Purple Hybrid Mattress If …
- Are a very hot sleeper who struggles to stay cool at night
- Are part of a couple
- Like to switch between sleeping positions
- Don’t like the feeling of being cradled by your mattress
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about Brooklyn and Purple mattresses:
Question: Do I have to flip Brooklyn Bedding or Purple mattresses?
Answer: No, neither mattresses require flipping – the layers are designed in a certain way, and you will enjoy the benefits of these mattresses if you leave them the correct way up. They’re durable, so you won’t have to worry about dips forming.
However, the Brooklyn Signature needs to be rotated every 6-8 months (but not flipped!).
Question: Where are Brooklyn Bedding and Purple mattresses manufactured?
Answer: Both companies manufacture their mattresses in the USA.
Question: Do I need to leave my new mattress to ‘settle’ before I use it?
Answer: Ideally, with any boxed mattress, you should leave it for 48 hours to completely decompress. Although it does decompress a lot straight out of the box, it can take a couple of days to get to the final shape and size.
Question: Can you recommend any alternatives?
Answer: Yes, we’ve reviewed a few mattresses that you may be interested in:
- WinkBeds – WinkBeds offers luxurious 15” hybrid mattresses, with 4 firmness levels to choose from, making it comparable to the Brooklyn Signature. You can read more about it in our WinkBeds vs DreamCloud comparison.
- Sealy – Sealy’s Posturepedic mattress is a hybrid that offers a lot of support for those suffering from back pain. It’s worth checking out if you do have a lot of back pain at night. You can read more about it in our Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Mattress review.
- TempurPedic – This is another great option for those suffering from back pain. TempurPedic offers a hybrid mattress that gives good support and spinal alignment. You can find out more about it in our Novaform vs TempurPedic comparison
Our Final Thoughts – Which is the Best Mattress for You?
Which one is best for you?
That’s a tough one. We like both the hybrid mattresses that Brooklyn Bedding and Purple has to offer. We also like the warranties and test times offered. Ultimately, if you choose to try them and you don’t like them, you can send them back again, which makes shopping online for mattresses less of a risk.
We’d pick the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid if we had to pick one winner. It’s a lot cheaper than the Purple Hybrid, which is a big consideration if you’re on a tighter budget.
We like that you can choose your firmness level, and we think it’s a durable mattress that works well for most people. Plus, although it’s not as cool as the Purple Hybrid, it still works pretty well for hot sleepers.
However – if you like the technology that Purple mattresses provide with their grid layer, and you want to enjoy a very cooling mattress, you might want to choose them. Purple mattresses have a great reputation, they’re durable, and the hybrid works well for most weights and sleeping positions.
We hope this has helped you to figure out which one is best for you! You can find out more about them by reading our other articles: